Identity, Access and Data

Password Storage and Authentication Review

Review password storage, verification and recovery against online and offline compromise scenarios. Findings support credential protection, secure migration and consistent account access controls.

IDN 045 min read9 sections

01 / Overview

Assessment objectives and control obligations

The review examines password-verifier design, salted hashing parameters, computational work factors and protection of supplementary secrets using implementation evidence. Legacy migration and rehash conditions are evaluated against operational capacity. Online guessing and offline database compromise are modelled separately because their defensive dependencies differ.

Registration, verification, recovery and session transitions are assessed for enumeration, replay, token reuse and alternate-route bypass. Controlled accounts establish revocation and recovery behaviour without unnecessary disclosure of credentials. Any offline strength estimate retains the authorised sample, hardware assumptions and workload parameters supporting the conclusion.

02 / Technical analysis

Failure mechanisms and security implications

Online rate limiting does not protect an exported password database. Strong hashing does not resolve a reusable reset token. We separate attacker positions and identify the mechanism responsible for each exposure.

03 / Scope

Technical coverage and authorisation boundaries

Coverage is agreed in writing before testing begins. The rows below describe what this service normally examines. Exclusions, testing windows and escalation contacts are recorded in the rules of engagement.

Secret storage
Hashing parameters, salt generation, additional secrets and legacy migration.
Verification and recovery
Response behaviour, attempt limits, reset tokens and identity checks.
Sessions
Signing, lifetime, renewal and revocation after credential events.
Supporting tools
Environment-appropriate instrumentation may include hashcat, John the Ripper, Burp Suite, Verification harnesses. Selection follows the investigative objective, compatibility requirements and approved operating constraints. Automated output requires corroboration against implementation evidence or observed execution before classification as a substantiated finding.

04 / Methodology

Investigation and validation methodology

Control review evaluates design adequacy and operating effectiveness against an explicit baseline. Sampling rationale, implementation evidence, exceptions and analytical limitations are retained to support traceable conclusions and proportionate remediation.

  1. 01

    Objectives and evidence plan

    Preparation

    We agree the questions, applicable references and evidence sources, and authorise any sampling or active validation before collection.

  2. 02

    Review implementation and parameters

    Confirm storage design and representative legacy records.

  3. 03

    Check account transitions

    Use synthetic accounts to validate recovery and session changes.

  4. 04

    Priorities and handover

    Review completion

    Factual reconciliation precedes delivery of a risk-treatment roadmap identifying accountable owners, implementation dependencies and measurable verification criteria.

05 / Assessment options

Access models and evidential confidence

Supplied access determines investigative reach, validation depth and evidential confidence. The proposal records the access model, supporting material and unresolved coverage limitations; no model implies unrestricted authority or exhaustive verification.

Black box
Testing starts without supplied credentials or internal design material. External exposure is examined, while authenticated workflows may remain inaccessible.
Grey box
Representative accounts and selected design information support direct comparison of roles, tenants and sensitive workflows.
White box
Source, configuration and design evidence support root cause analysis. Runtime and access limitations are still recorded.

06 / Deliverables

Decision-support and verification deliverables

Deliverables distinguish what was observed, what was concluded and where the evidence stops. The agreed scope states which evidence, review sessions and retesting are included.

Executive summary

The summary explains the demonstrated exposure, the business functions affected and the treatment decisions required, including material uncertainty.

Technical findings

Each confirmed issue records the affected assets, prerequisites, reproduction evidence and a specific remediation. Technical severity is presented separately from business priority.

Coverage and limitations

The record identifies the systems, identities and conditions tested, together with exclusions and assumptions that affect interpretation.

Treatment and retest status

Recommendations are sequenced by risk, dependency and ownership. Any agreed retest records resolved, partly resolved and unresolved issues without implying a new assessment.

Service specific evidence

Implementation references, parameter analysis and sanitised account tests support correction.

07 / References

Applicable technical references

References are selected for the technology and objective in scope, and the edition applied is recorded. A framework mapping supports review; it is not certification or proof of complete compliance.

NIST digital identity guidance
Revision 4 authentication guidance informs authenticator lifecycle, assurance, recovery and verifier requirements. Its scope and any binding local obligations are considered explicitly.
OWASP Application Security Verification Standard
ASVS supplies verifiable application requirements. Requirements are selected for the architecture and assurance objective, with implementation evidence rather than a blanket compliance claim.

08 / Safeguards

Operational safeguards and evidence governance

Active work is conditional on written authority from the appropriate asset owner and approved rules of engagement. The operating plan specifies permitted procedures, testing windows, prohibited actions, third-party restrictions and nominated stop authority. Unexpected instability or suspected genuine compromise triggers suspension of affected activity pending the client’s operational decision.

Evidence governance applies purpose limitation, data minimisation and access proportionality to collection, transfer, processing, retention and disposal. The signed terms define authorised recipients and any external processing arrangement. Publication, secondary use and disclosure of client material require the applicable written permission.

Conclusions distinguish substantiated exposure, untested consequence and residual uncertainty. Each material finding identifies the control obligation, causal mechanism, observed outcome and verification criteria for the proposed treatment. Technical severity informs analysis; prioritisation and acceptance of residual risk remain decisions for the client’s authorised risk owner.

No unauthorised use of live hashes or credentials. Offline estimates retain hardware and workload assumptions.

09 / Suitability

Commissioning criteria

Use before authentication changes, credential migration or after suspected credential store exposure.

Next step

Define the assessment you need

Tell us the business decision, the systems involved and any operational constraint. We will explain the coverage proposed, the access required and the evidence the engagement can provide.

  • Confidentiality first

    A mutual confidentiality agreement is signed before any technical detail is exchanged, so scope discussions can happen safely.

  • Scope and cost in writing

    Deliverables, access expectations, timeline and fee are confirmed before the engagement begins, and a scope change needs agreement.

  • Answered by the delivery team

    The consultants who scope an engagement are the consultants who perform it and explain the result to your team.

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to keep the site working and analytics cookies to understand how you use it, so we can improve. We do not sell your data. See our Privacy Policy for details.